Between all the catchy names, proprietary materials, and endless reviews, finding the right mattress in a box can become a full-time job. Well, luckily for you. Comparing mattresses is our full-time job. So, if you’re stuck between a Nectar vs. Tuft and Needle bed, our review will have you unstuck in no time.
Need a quick answer: the basics Nectar vs. Tuft and Needle
With all the options when it comes to online mattress companies, Nectar and Tuft and Needle are probably the most comparable in price and quality. Although, we conclude that Tuft and Needle is a better option for most people. So, here’s a quick breakdown of what makes them alike and what sets them apart:
What does the Nectar mattress have in common with a Tuft and Needle Mattress?
- Both bed-in-a-box options are slightly more firm than soft
- Both get delivered to your door for free
- Both offer free returns
- Both have a 100-night sleep trial
- Both shine when it comes to customer service
- Both have donation policies for returned mattresses
- Both feature all-foam compositions
What sets the Tuft and Needle Bed apart from a Nectar mattress?
- Tuft and Needle is less expensive than a Nectar
- Nectar offers a Forever Warranty™
- Tuft and Needle is 10-inches tall
- Nectar is 11-inches tall
- Nectar uses memory foam while Tuft and Needle uses their patented Adaptive Foam
- Tuft and Needle has a slightly more springy feel
- Tuft and Needle has a better soft and supportive balance
- Tuft and Needle has overall more happy customers
Who has the better price? Nectar vs. Tuft and Needle
Price is always a top factor when it comes to the right mattress in a box. And once again, the Tuft and Needle mattress comes out on top for the price. It’s nearly impossible to beat the value of a Tuft and Needle. Without any coupons, promo codes, or sales, the Tuft and Needle bed is about $130 less expensive than the Nectar.
|Tuft and Needle||Nectar|
The Nectar does come with two pillows, though, if you’re in need of some new bedding.
The materials and layers: Tuft and Needle vs. Nectar
Tuft and Needle layers and material
Tuft and Needle is known for its ‘keep it simple and straightforward’ approach to a well-made mattress-in-a-box. A Tuft and Needle Original doesn’t have any unnecessary frills–it’s two simple, yet proprietary, layers that the majority of sleepers find comfortable.
What are Tuft and Needle’s two layers?
Tuft and Needle uses two layers of T&N Adaptive foam to achieve a comfortable balance between its soft top and firmer base layer.
The top layer is comprised of three-inches of open-cell polyfoam that responds to your weight, curves, and pressure. It’s soft, yet you won’t feel that ‘ever-sink’ sensation of generic foam beds.
The base layer is 7-inches of slightly denser open-cell polyfoam. This thick and robust base prevents you from sinking too deep but cradles your weight without creating pressure points.
Why materials matter in a Tuft and Needle
The Tuft and Needle is made from environmentally friendly polyfoam infused with gel and graphite. The exact makeup of the material is proprietary, but its name holds true: T&N Adaptive foam. The foam does respond quickly to weight and movement. This makes for superior movement isolation and feels more springy than memory foam.
Do the gel and graphite work to cool you as you sleep? You bet they do. Graphite naturally absorbs heat, and gel remains in a semi-liquid form, this mattress is, in fact, cooler than most, including the Nectar. In addition to the gel and graphite, the open-cell foam offers better breathability and heat transference.
What’s a Nectar mattress made of?
Let’s look at the layers of a Nectar mattress
Following many others in the mattress in a box industry, a Nectar bed features more layers than a Tuft and Needle. The Nectar is designed with four layers. Nectar describes its bed as a “5-Layer-foam construction,” but the base cover is equivalent to Tuft and Needle’s cover, so we don’t count it as a layer.
Here’s what a Nectar is made from the top, down.
Usually, we don’t count the top cover as a layer, since it doesn’t account for much, we do when it comes to the Nectar. Why? The Nectar has a top layer made from quilted memory foam, which means it has a 1-inch depth and added comfort when compared to other beds. We like that the quilted design is both stylish and pillowy. It feels more luxurious than most other bed-in-a-box options. It’s also removable!
Beneath the quilted top, you’ll find three inches of gel memory foam layer. Like the Tuft and Needle’s gel-infused foam, this one won’t trap heat against your body. Notice Nectar doesn’t have graphite to help absorb heat.
Nectar added an adaptive one-inch hi-core transition foam layer between their light layer and dense layer to prevent too much sinkage.
Finally, you’ll find the six-inch base layer at the bottom of a Nectar mattress. This layer adds stability and support to cushion your weight.
The materials that go into a Nectar bed
Nectar includes a wider variety of polyfoams than Tuft and Needle, which has some advantages and some disadvantages.
Nectar uses traditional memory foam, which tends to heat up more than Tuft and Needle’s T&N Adaptive® foam. Memory foam also feels more… well… foamy. While Nectar does have a transition layer between its top layer and the base layer to help limit the sinking feeling, you’ll still feel a bit of that ‘I’m-sinking-and-I-can’t-get-up’ sensation.
The Tencel cooling cover that comes with a Nectar mattress is a beautiful addition. It offers customers a little adjustability when it comes to how soft the bed feels.
Our verdict when it comes to layers and materials: Nectar vs. Tuft and Needle
Better for those who sleep hot: Tuft and Needle
Better overall balance of softness and support: Tuft and Needle
Better movement isolation: Nectar
Better cover: Nectar
Better pressure relief: Tuft and Needle
How do you sleep? Comparing how you’d rest based on your sleep position: Nectar vs. Tuft and Needle
Whether you dream with your face down in the pillow or doze off spooning your partner, your sleep position affects which option is the best bed in a box for you.
Which bed is better for back sleepers?
Because back sleepers need more lumbar support, the Tuft and Needle offers better sleep for back sleepers. The T&N Adaptive® foam provides superior lower back and hip support.
Which mattress do side sleepers prefer?
Most of us, including me, are side sleepers. And most women that sleep on their sides tend to prefer the Nectar since it offers just a bit more room for your hips to sink. And the transition layer doesn’t leave you with any pressure points on your hips. Most male side sleepers didn’t report a noticeable difference.
Which beds gives sleepers the best rest?
The Tuft and Needle leaves tummy sleepers better rested. The firmness of the T&N Adaptive® foam results in enough support to support your hips.
Which mattress-in-a-box is best for cuddling the Tuft and Needle vs. Nectar?
The quilted cover and transitional support layer in the Nectar mattress make it a better option for couples that fall asleep spooning or continue cuddling through the night.
Which bed-in-a-box is better for sex? Nectar vs. Tuft and Needle
So, we didn’t test this out ourselves. It seemed a little too personal, but we did check Reddit to see which bed couples preferred, and the results confirmed our hypothesis and what other experts had to say. Most couples prefer to have sex on Tuft and Needle. Redditors like the slight spring that T& N Adaptive® foam provides. The Tuft and Needle also left couples less sweaty.
The Nectar bed’s memory foam made transitioning from one position to another more cumbersome and awkward.
What are the most common complaints? Nectar vs. Tuft and Needle
There is no such thing as the perfect mattress. When there is, we will let you know. In the meantime, comparing the most frequent complaints and praises of these two beds can help you make up your mind on which to buy.
Overall, Tuft and Needle has more positive and fewer negative reviews than Nectar.
Most Common criticisms of the Tuft and Needle Original
- It doesn’t offer enough support for people with back issues
- The mattress settles over time, becoming softer
- The transition between the top and bottom layer is too abrupt
- The bed is firmer than average foam mattress options
Nectar mattress complaints: here’s what customers say in their Nectar mattress reviews
- Irregularities in bed expansion
- Persistent chemical smell
- Sleeps hot
- Requires a mattress topper
- Sinkage feels like its enveloping you
- Memory foam doesn’t respond quick enough when repositioning
Most common raves: Nectar vs. Tuft and Needle
What do those people that take the time to review the bed they love have to say? Here are the most frequent raves about these beds:
What do Tuft and Needle users say?
- Alleviated hip and back pain
- Comfy and cool
- Great support
- Good quality for the price
- Excellent customer service
What do Nectar sleepers love about their beds?
- You sink in just enough
- Very comfortable
- Good for the budget
- Two free pillows
Which bed is better for you? Nectar vs. Tuft and Needle
Tuft and Needle wins this battle of the beds. It outperforms in value for money and reliability in the product quality. The Tuft and Needle’s simple two-layer system seems to expand more evenly and offer better cooling and consistent comfort. While these beds are comparable, Tuft and Needle just performs slightly better for more people overall.