When it comes to comparing mattresses, the task of choosing the best bed in a box for you becomes tedious once you narrow down to the top brands. If you’ve landed on Purple and Tuft and Needle beds, great work! Both have faithful followings of happy customers. So, which one is the best mattress in a box for you: a Purple Mattress vs. Tuft & Needle?
If you’ve read several Purple mattress reviews and Tuft and Needle reviews until the words blurred together and you’re still on the fence, this buying guide is for you.
We talked to diehard fans of both Purple and Tuft and Needle to help better understand what each group loves about their beds. Of course, both have some great benefits, but both also have a couple of drawbacks. We sorted through the details and organized the results to help you decide if a Purple or Tuft and Needle bed is better for your sleep needs.
Who has the better price? Purple mattress vs.Tuft & Needle
A quality mattress comes with a price tag. What that pricetag says varies from brand to brand. If you’re a budget-conscious consumer, you’ll be pleased to learn that a Tuft and Needle bed is one of the least costly on the market.
Does Tuft and Needle cut corners to achieve this price? No. One of the company’s missions is to make great mattresses affordable to most people. In other words, they could charge more.
How much less expensive is a Tuft and Needle mattress compared to a Purple mattress?
A Tuft and Needle bed is about half the price of a Purple.
Here’s the price comparison chart that shows the breakdown:
|Tuft and Needle||Purple|
Keep in mind that you can sometimes find Purple mattress coupon codes and Tuft and Needle coupon codes. Purple also has more sales and promos throughout the year. They’ll throw in free sheets or a Purple pillow from time to time.
Purple Mattress vs.Tuft & Needle: the materials and layers
So what exactly are you paying for when you purchase a Purple bed or a Tuft and Needle bed? Both beds arrive on your doorstep tightly packed in a box, both take a day or two to expand, and both brands allow you to try the mattress for 100 nights with a full refund if you aren’t happy.
Is a trial necessary? Probably not. If you want a higher-end mattress with more layers, the Purple is a better option. The Tuft and Needle is a better option for those that want simple construction and comfort for a reasonable price.
Tuft and Needle’s layers and materials
A Tuft and Needle bed doesn’t claim to have material made by NASA or more layers than you can count. And they exemplify the idea that simple is better sometimes. Or, like we say, “the more that goes into it, the more that can go wrong.”
The Tuft and Needle Original comprised of two layers and a cover.
The top layer of a Tuft and Needle is 3-inches of cooling, open-cell T&N Adaptaive® foam. When you lie down, this soft layer compresses and conforms to your body. When you roll over, it springs back quickly, so you don’t feel like you’re trapped or stuck.
The top layer rests on the 7-inch Tuft and Needle support layer. This layer is also open-cell foam but is denser to bolster your weight.
Tuft and Needle materials
What makes a Tuft and Needle better than a generic bed in a box off Amazon? Tuft and Needle infuse their poly foam with graphite and cooling gel. These move heat away from your body instead of trapping it against your skin, leaving you refreshed and well-rested.
How does the Tuft and Needle mattress feel?
So, we can describe materials and layers all day, but what you really want to know is what does this bed feel like? Tuft and Needle used hundreds of test sleepers to perfect their ‘formula.’ So, this bed is made to please the majority of people.
The Tuft and Needle
- Is slightly more firm than soft
- Feels slightly bouncy compared to most foam beds
- Doesn’t heat up as you sleep
- Has better edge support than most foam beds
- Responds quickly to movement
- Absorbs and doesn’t transfer movement
Purple Mattress: layers and materials
A Purple mattress is more ‘rocket science’ than simplicity. A Purple bed consists of three layers and a cover.
The top layer of a Purple is a two-inch layer of Purple Grid™. This layer has a waffle-like pattern of purple squares that give way when you lie down. It’s soft and squishy to relieve pressure points.
The layer beneath the grid is 3.5-inches thick of higher density polyfoam to absorb your body’s weight.
The base layer is 4-inches of denser polyfoam.
What is Purple Grid?
Purple Grid is a patented polyfoam with a powder coating. This provides more elasticity than typical polyfoams. It feels more like latex than other mattress-in-a-box options. It also holds together, allowing air channels and the grid design.
How does a Purple bed feel?
A Purple bed, like the Tuft and Needle, leans more towards the firm side of beds. When you lie a Purple, you feel the hug of the grid that allows your hips and shoulders to sink while supporting your waist and legs. This mattress also stands with its promise to keep you from overheating through the night.
What you need to know to compare a Purple Mattress vs. a Tuft and Needle’s materials
The construction of the layers of a Purple Mattress vs. a Tuft and Needle bed results in a similar support-level.
Both have a light-density top layer that tailors support to your body’s curves, weight, and contours with a denser layer beneath.
Both offer night-long cooling. Tuft and Needle uses gel and graphite to transfer heat while Purple’s open-air grid helps dissipate heat.
Both beds are durable.
The Tuft and Needle comes with a beautiful cover that is soft and breathable.
The Purple features a SoftFlex cover that allows air to escape the grid when pressure or weight lands on it. It’s a soft, breathable knit material that feels more stretchy than the Tuft and Needle cover.
Comparing sleep positions: Purple Mattress vs.Tuft & Needle:
Your sleep position will assist in determining which these beds is best for you and your partner. Most people sleep on their sides, either curled or elongated, while others find a variation of back or belly sleep more comfortable.
Which do side sleepers prefer?
If you sleep on your side, you’re not alone. This is the most popular sleep position. People that rest this way would probably prefer a Tuft and Needle. Why? The Tuft and Needle has a thicker top layer, allowing your hips and shoulders to sink deeper, alleviating more stress and pressure and providing more support to the rest of your body.
Which bed provides better sleep for belly sleepers
If you’re one of the 7% of people that prefer this down-tummy nighttime position, you would likely sleep better on the Purple. The Purple Grid offers a bit more nuanced support for stomach sleepers.
Which bed is better for back sleepers?
Do you dream best on your back? Then you’re part of the 8% of people that choose this healthy sleep position, and you’d likely find more restful sleep on a Purple than a Tuft and Needle.
Who makes the best bed-in-a-box for children?
More parents choose the Tuft and Needle for their kids than a Purple. Parents find the price accounts for exceptional value, and their kids rest through the night on Tuft and Needle beds. These beds also provide support from toddler-hood to teen years.
The most common complaints: Tuft and Needle vs. Purple reviews
Finally, we want to address the complaints some users had with these beds. Like we said, neither of these mattresses is without its flaws. So, what do users most often complain about when it comes to a Purple mattress vs. Tuft and Needle beds?
Most common complaints about the Purple
Overall, Purple had more users that rated it with a 1 out of 5, and many unhappy customers referenced the price and “hype” of the bed as part of their disappointment. More people complained about the construction and the quality of sleep with a Purple.
- Not worth the price
- Sleeps hot
- Uneven length in layers
- Unstable edge/Lacks edge support
- Deformed grid/cubes
- Users sink to the denser layer
- Users noticed pressure points and discomfort over time
- Gets softer over time
- Hip pain for side sleepers
- You need special sheets for optimal comfort
Most common complaints about the Tuft and Needle bed
Overall, fewer people complained about “feeling ripped off” with the Tuft and Needle, but more people complained about sleep quality.
- It takes a few months to settle/Losing firmness
- Users can feel the transition between the soft top layer and the dense layer
- More firm than expected
- Could have better edge support
- Woke up sore
- Didn’t help or users report back discomfort
Most common raves: Purple Mattress vs. Tuft and Needle
What do people who love their beds have to say about Purple vs. Tuft and Needle? There are a few patterns we picked up on that you’ll be happy to know about.
Frequent raves in Purple mattress reviews
- Super comfortable
- Soft yet firm
- Felt zero pressure points
- Great if you have back problems
- Less tossing and turning than before
- Easy setup
Tuft and Needle mattress review raves
- Woke up without pain or soreness
- Firm and comfy
- Great support
- Great quality
- Great price
It’s time to make up your mind: Tuft and Needle vs. Purple
What do these beds have in common? Tuft and Needle vs. Purple
- Both top-rated mattresses offer cooling, comfort, and moderate firmness.
- Both have 100-day sleep trials and 10-year warranties.
- Both have softer top layers and firmer support base layers.
- Both sit standard bedding and come in a range of bed sizes.
- You can order both a Purple or a Tuft and Needle off Amazon or their websites.
- Both have designs that support cooling.
What are the major differences between the Purple mattress and Tuft and Needle beds
- A Purple mattress is about twice the price of a Tuft and Needle.
- Purple offers better support for back and belly sleepers.
- Tuft and Needle is preferred for side sleepers.
- Tuft and Needle has 2 layers, a 3-inch soft top and a 7-inch denser base.
- Purple has 3 layers, a 2-inch softer top and 2 base layers that are denser.
Rest well on the best bed-in-a-box for you
While we can’t order for you, we hope our Tuft and Needle vs. Purple review gave you the insight you need to choose which bed-in-a-box is right for you. If you’re on a budget but want a quality bed that will last, choose the Tuft and Needle. For those that experience chronic back pain, sleep on their backs or bellies, you may want to invest in a Purple.